Free will

There is no generally accepted definition for the term free will or freedom of will, and whether or not freedom of will exists at all is disputed. Colloquially, free will is understood to mean something different than in legal or psychological usage. Even in philosophy, the term is not uniformly defined. In an interdisciplinary sense, freedom of will includes the subjectively perceived human ability to make a conscious decision when faced with various choices.

Rudolf Steiner's views on the freedom of will

According to Rudolf Steiner, to speak of the freedom of the will is pure nonsense. Rather, the freedom of the human being lies in the fact that he can recognise the laws of his actions and base his decisions on them. The starting point of freedom is therefore never the will, which reigns deep below the threshold of consciousness, but rather the freedom of thought, which man can attain in pure, sensuality-free thinking through moral intuition and thereby freely shape his actions. With good reason, therefore, Marquis von Posa says to King Philip II in Schiller's "Don Karlos": "Give freedom of thought!" - and not: "Give freedom of will!"

„Read in my "Philosophy of Freedom" what great importance I have attached to not asking about the freedom of will. It sits below, deep down in the unconscious, and it is nonsense to ask about the freedom of will; one can only speak of the freedom of thought. I have kept this apart in my "Philosophy of Freedom". Free thoughts must then impulse the will, and then man is free.“ (Lit.:GA 235, p. 46ff)

Freedom as freedom of thought - Rudolf Steiner's "Philosophy of Freedom"

→ Main article: The Philosophy of Freedom

Rudolf Steiner dealt with the question of human freedom in particular in his fundamental philosophical work "The Philosophy of Freedom" (CW 4).

The book consists of two main parts, each of which is divided into seven chapters. "The Science of Freedom", the first main part, poses the core question: "Is man in his thinking and acting a spiritually free being or is he under the constraint of a purely natural, iron necessity?" This question is more topical than ever at the beginning of the 21st century. Brain research, which has taken off in a big way in recent decades, declares - supported by a wealth of empirical evidence - not only human freedom but also the human "I" to be a mere illusion, rising like a bubble from largely unconscious brain processes that have gradually emerged in the course of natural evolution. That an action whose true reasons we do not see through cannot be free is evident. "But what about one whose reasons are known?" This raises the question of the nature and value of thinking, for without it no knowledge is possible, not even of the reasons that determine our actions.

Observation and thinking are the two starting points for all conscious human striving for knowledge. I may observe a horse for as long as I like, but the concept of the horse will never emerge of its own accord before I have formed it myself through thinking. Consciousness is the arena where concept and observation meet. Only in their union do I grasp the full reality.

Now, it is in the peculiar nature of thinking that we carry it out, but do not usually observe it, because we are completely devoted to the object we are thinking about. We have to create a state of exception, so to speak, if we want to observe our own thinking. Every human being can do this and it is the most important observation he can make, because now the consciousness is directed in continuous clarity exclusively towards his own mental activity. He grasps himself as a spiritual being and awakens to the actual "consciousness of his humanity" - this is the true meaning of the word "anthroposophy", which Rudolf Steiner used to describe the spiritual science he founded years later.

Contrary to popular opinion, thinking is not abstract and empty of content, but produces its own content, in which, however, the essence of the things I observe is revealed. Of course, we can make many mistakes and be subject to errors before we apply the right concepts to things. In the end, however, their lawfulness is expressed in them. Thus thinking is at the same time an actively working mental organ of perception. I can only recognise that a thrown stone follows an approximately parabolic path if I have formed the concept of the parabola through thinking. I can never gain it through external observation. It is present to me through intuition, through a purely spiritual experience of a purely spiritual content. The physicist Walter Heitler rightly said: "According to this, the law of nature would be an archetype, an "idea" - in the sense of the Greek word eidea - which nature follows and which man can perceive. This is then what is called the idea. Through this archetype, man is connected with nature."

"The reality of freedom" is dealt with in the second main part of the "Philosophy of Freedom", in which Rudolf Steiner outlines the foundations of a future ethical individualism. Those who allow themselves to be guided in their actions only by their drives, by habits or by externally given commandments do not act freely. Only those who draw the reasons for their actions from pure thinking act freely and self-determinedly. He then acts out of moral intuition, through which he determines the lawfulness of his actions himself, adapts it to the given life situation through moral fantasy and implements it concretely through an appropriate moral technique. Nothing compels him, he acts out of insight and love for what he does. Misunderstanding is impossible between morally free people, since they draw their individual moral ideals from the world of ideas common to all.

This gives rise to the oft-quoted basic maxim of free people:

"Living in the love of action and let live in the understanding of the will of others is the fundamental maxim of free men." (Lit.:GA 4, p. 130)

The will in thinking as the basis of freedom

„Just think if you lived purely reflectively for a while in the sense of the ordinary sciences, if you did not move at all, if you completely refrained from all action, if you lived a life of imagination. But you must be clear that in this life of imagination will is active, will which, however, is then active in your inner being, which spreads its powers in the realm of imagination. When we look at the thinking man in this way, how he continually radiates will into his thoughts, then one thing must actually strike us in comparison with real life. The thoughts that we grasp when we go through them all - we will always find that they are connected with something in our surroundings, something among our experiences. Between birth and death we have, as it were, no other thoughts than those which life brings us. If our experience is rich, we also have a rich thought-content; if our experience is poor, we have a poor thought-content. The thought-content is, so to speak, our inner destiny. But within this thought-experience, one thing is entirely our own: The way we connect and disconnect thoughts, the way we inwardly process thoughts, the way we judge, the way we draw conclusions, the way we orient ourselves in thought-life in general, that is ours, is peculiar to us. The will in our thought life is our own.

When we look at this thought-life, we must say to ourselves, and you will see that this is the case with a careful self-examination: the thoughts come to us from outside according to their content, the processing of the thoughts comes from us. - Basically, therefore, we are entirely dependent on what we can experience in our world of thoughts through the birth into which we are fated, through the experiences that can come to us. But into that which comes to us from the outer world we carry our own, precisely through the will which radiates from the depths of the soul. For the fulfilment of what self-knowledge demands of us human beings, it is of great importance that we distinguish between the thought content that comes to us from the environment on the one hand, and the power of the will that radiates from within us into the world of thought on the other.

How does one actually become more and more spiritual inwardly? One does not become more spiritual by absorbing as many thoughts as possible from the environment, for these thoughts only, I would say, reproduce the outer world, which is a sensual-physical world, in images. By running after the sensations of life as much as possible, one does not become more spiritual. One becomes more spiritual through inner willful work within the thoughts. That is why meditation consists in not indulging in a random play of thoughts, but in placing a few easily comprehensible, easily verifiable thoughts in the centre of one's consciousness, but in placing these thoughts in the centre of one's consciousness with a strong will. And the stronger, the more intense this inner ray of will becomes in the element where the thoughts are, the more spiritual we become. If we take up thoughts from the outer physical-sensuous world - and we can only take up such thoughts between birth and death - then, as you can easily see, we become unfree, for we are given over to the connections of the outer world; we must then think as the outer world dictates, insofar as we only consider the thought content; only in the inner processing do we become free.

Now there is a possibility of becoming completely free, of becoming free in one's inner life, if one excludes, as far as possible, the content of thought, in so far as it comes from outside, more and more and more, and puts the will element, which radiates through our thoughts in judging, in drawing conclusions, into special activity. This, however, puts our thinking into that state which I have called pure thinking in my "Philosophy of Freedom". We think, but only will lives in thinking. I emphasised this particularly sharply in the new edition of the "Philosophy of Freedom" in 1918. That which lives in us lives in the sphere of thinking. But when it has become pure thinking, it can just as well be spoken of as pure will. So that we rise from thinking to the will, when we become inwardly free, that we make our thinking so mature, so to speak, that it is completely permeated by the will, no longer absorbs from without, but lives in the will. But it is precisely by strengthening the will more and more in thought that we prepare ourselves for what I have called in the "Philosophy of Freedom" the moral fantasy, but which rises to the moral intuitions which then radiate through, enforce our will that has become thought or thought that has become will. In this way we lift ourselves out of physical-sensual necessity, radiate through ourselves with what is proper to us and prepare ourselves for moral intuition. And it is on such moral intuitions that all that can at first fulfil man from the spiritual world is based. It lives, then, on that which is freedom, when in our very thinking we let the will become more and more powerful.“ (Lit.:GA 202, p. 200ff)

Literature

• Rudolf Steiner: Die Philosophie der Freiheit, GA 4 (1995), ISBN 3-7274-0040-4; Tb 627, ISBN 978-3-7274-6271-9 English: rsarchive.org German: pdf pdf(2) html mobi epub archive.org
• Rudolf Steiner: Schriften. Kritische Ausgabe / Band 2: Philosophische Schriften: Wahrheit und Wissenschaft. Die Philosophie der Freiheit, frommann-holzboog, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt 2016, ISBN 978-3772826320
• Rudolf Steiner: Die Philosophie der Freiheit, Mit beiden Ausgaben (1894 u. 1918) im Vergleich, Rudolf Steiner Ausgaben, 3. Aufl. 2015, ISBN 978-3-86772-072-4
• Rudolf Steiner: Geschichtliche Notwendigkeit und Freiheit. Schicksalseinwirkungen aus der Welt der Toten, GA 179 (1993), ISBN 3-7274-1790-0 English: rsarchive.org German: pdf pdf(2) html mobi epub archive.org
• Rudolf Steiner: Die Brücke zwischen der Weltgeistigkeit und dem Physische des Menschen, GA 202 (1993), ISBN 3-7274-2020-0 English: rsarchive.org German: pdf pdf(2) html mobi epub archive.org
• Rudolf Steiner: Esoterische Betrachtungen karmischer Zusammenhänge. Erster Band, GA 235 (1994), ISBN 3-7274-2350-1 English: rsarchive.org German: pdf pdf(2) html mobi epub archive.org
• Rudolf Steiner: Neugestaltung des sozialen Organismus, GA 330 (1983), ISBN 3-7274-3300-0 English: rsarchive.org German: pdf pdf(2) html mobi epub archive.org

References to the work of Rudolf Steiner follow Rudolf Steiner's Collected Works (CW or GA), Rudolf Steiner Verlag, Dornach/Switzerland, unless otherwise stated. Email: verlag@steinerverlag.com URL: www.steinerverlag.com. Index to the Complete Works of Rudolf Steiner - Aelzina Books A complete list by Volume Number and a full list of known English translations you may also find at Rudolf Steiner's Collected Works Rudolf Steiner Archive - The largest online collection of Rudolf Steiner's books, lectures and articles in English. Rudolf Steiner Audio - Recorded and Read by Dale Brunsvold steinerbooks.org - Anthroposophic Press Inc. (USA) Rudolf Steiner Handbook - Christian Karl's proven standard work for orientation in Rudolf Steiner's Collected Works for free download as PDF.